Social c ontract essay

Mary, a frail but mentally sound year old woman, is in the front garden of her old weatherboard home. Duncan, a big man who was heavily tattooed and wearing leathers, parks his motorbike outside her garden and strikes up a conversation with Mary. He told Mary that: Mary obviously felt intimidated by Duncan and hastily agreed.

Social c ontract essay

May be copied with attribution for noncommercial purposes. Between and the Framers of the U. Constitution established a system of government upon principles that had been discussed and partially implemented in many countries over the course of several centuries, but never before in such a pure and complete design, which we call a constitutional republic.

Since then, the design has often been imitated, but important principles have often been ignored in those imitations, with the result that their governments fall short of being true republics or truly constitutional.

Neil MacCormick

Although these principles are discussed in civics books, the treatment of them there is often less than satisfactory.

This essay will attempt to remedy some of the deficiencies of those treatments. The Social Contract and Government The fundamental basis for government and law in this system is the concept of the social contract, according to which human Social c ontract essay begin as individuals in a state of nature, and create a society by establishing a contract whereby they agree to live together in harmony for their mutual benefit, after which they are said to live in a state of society.

This contract involves the retaining of certain natural rights, an acceptance of restrictions of certain liberties, the assumption of certain duties, and the pooling of certain powers to be exercised collectively.

The social contract is very simple. It has only two basic Social c ontract essay There are no agents, no officials, that persist from one deliberative assembly to another.

The duties of the social contract are militia. There may be customs that persist from assembly to assembly, such as customs for due notice, parliamentary procedure, judicial due process, and enforcement of court orders by militia. This second term could be called the constitution of society, but it precedes a constitution of government and should not be confused with it.

There is also a constitution of nature that precedes both the constitution of society and the constitution of government.

It is also convenient to speak of a constitution of the dominion that follows the constitution of society and precedes the constitution of government. It arises after a society is created by adopting the social contractand after it acquires exclusive dominion over a well-defined territory.

A constitution of government, such as the Constitution ofis the next step in the development. It is to establish institutions, offices, procedures, duties, and structures that persist from one assembly to another that are not just customs.

It is at that point that we begin to get things like laws, and paid agents and officials, whose jobs continue beyond transient assemblies. We also get taxes, standing armies, and professional law enforcers. Such pooled powers are generally exercised by delegating them to some members of the society to act as agents for the members of the society as a whole, and to do so within a framework of structure and procedures that is a government.

No such government may exercise any powers not thus delegated to it, or do so in a way that is not consistent with established structures or procedures defined by a basic law which is called the constitution. While it is possible in principle for such a constitution to consist entirely of a body of unwritten practices, traditions, court decisions, and long-established statutes, in practice no such basic order can be considered secure against confusion or corruption if it is not primarily based on a written document, which prescribes the structure, procedures, and delegated powers of government, and the retained rights of the people, and which is strictly interpreted according to the original intent of the framers.

Although in principle the procedures may allow for the direct adoption of legislation by vote of the people, this is both impractical and potentially dangerous, especially to the rights of minorities, so that it is generally best that most legislation require approval at some point in the legislative process by a deliberative assembly, a body of elected representatives rather than by direct popular vote, and that any such legislation be subject to judicial review, whereby legislation not consistent with the constitution can be voided.

Such a form of government is called a republic, as distinct from a democracy, in which all legislation is adopted solely by direct popular vote. And if it operates under a well-designed constitution, it is a constitutional republic. It is important that the deliberative assembly fairly represent all the competing interests of the people, so that the concerns of minorities can be weighed and not ignored.

But fair representation is insufficient if deliberation is not effective in analyzing and anticipating all the consequences of any decisions that might be made. The consent of the majority should be necessary for action, but that consent should never be sufficient for action.

Origins of the Social Contract Critics of social contract theory argue that almost all persons grow up within an existing society, and therefore never have the choice of whether to enter into a social contract. Not having a choice, they say, makes any such contract void.

Social c ontract essay

The original proponents of the social contract theory, John Locke, David Hume, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, answered these critics, but not in a way that is entirely satisfactory. To understand how the social contract comes about, we need to look at the kinds of contract that prevail during each stage in the development of a human being in society.

Each of us begins life under the terms of a special kind of social contract called a filial contract, between a child and his parents, and by extension to his siblings. That contract is established at the moment of bonding between parents and child following birth, and the terms of the contract are that the child will provide the parents certain pleasures that come with parenthood, particularly the satisfaction of helping to form a happy and admirable adult, and support for the parents in their later years, and in turn receives their love, support, guidance, and protection during childhood.

Although a filial contract can exist in a family that is isolated from any larger society, when the parents join a society, they pool their rights and duties as parents with other members of that society, and thereby become agents of the larger society in the raising of their own children, and accountable to that larger society for doing so properly.

Social c ontract essay

As a child grows, it encounters other members of the larger society, usually beginning with other children. Whenever any two or more individuals meet with the understanding and expectation that they will live together in harmony and not fight with one another using any available means, they are establishing a social contract among themselves.It is now clear that Social Contract theory does not work, and it is also clear why it does not work.

Both men talked about rights, and obligations, and laws, and central authority, but they failed to account for the serpent in the straw which is the problem of power. Short essay on social contract theory of the origin of society. The social contract theory throws light on the origin of the society.

According to this theory all men are born free and equal. JOURNAL OF GENDER, SOCIAL POLICY & THE LAW [Vol. I. INTRODUCTION The school of thought known as Economic Analysis of Law (Law & Economics) uses economic principles to determine whether a legal outcome is efficient for society as a whole.3 The increasing popularity of this movement stems from its logical neatness and its broad.

The Puzzle of the Optimal Social Composition of Neighborhoods, in THE TIEBOUT MODEL AT F IFTY: E SSAYS IN P UBLIC E CONOMICS IN H ONOR OF W .

The Social Contract Questions and Answers. The Question and Answer section for The Social Contract is a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel. Essay on Social Contract Theory – The ‘social contract theory’ throws light on the origin of the society.

According to this theory, all men are born free and equal. According to .

Social Contract Theory