Disney vs brothers grims essay

Disney Cinderella Disney could not have made an exact remake of the fairytale. The Brothers Grimm telling is not Disney acceptable; more on that later. The Movie, of course has, Cinderella, a wicked stepmother, and wicked stepsisters.

Disney vs brothers grims essay

A Comparative Analysis of Snow White Snow White became a part of the Grimm Brothers' fairy tales in and was made into a classic, feature length film by the Walt Disney company in The physical description of Snow White is important because Disney kept it in his adaptation and even parts of her famous costume are retained by both Mirror, Mirror and Snow White and the Huntsman.

Featured Post

The Grimm Brothers' tale reads: Once upon a time in midwinter, when the snowflakes were falling like feathers from heaven, a queen sat sewing at her window, which had a frame of black ebony wood. As Disney vs brothers grims essay sewed she looked up at the snow and pricked her finger with her needle.

Three drops of blood fell into the snow. The red on the white looked so beautiful that she thought to herself, "If only I had a child as white as snow, as red as blood, and as black as the wood in this frame.

And as soon as the child was born, the queen died. It's mid-winter, so things have been cold and are going to stay cold, and the idea of a queen sewing is a prime image of the spiritual life, because each of us is called to be royalty in our souls but this woman is royalty in the material world; when we have success in life, we undoubtedly turn to the spiritual and want more out of life than just the material, and what it is we are to be sewing?

The bridal gown, the "new man" that Christ calls each of us to put on, on the gown of virtue and love. The queen getting distracted by what happens outside the window is why she pricks her finger: Knowing she became distracted, and recognizing the spiritual qualities she herself should have been exercising more on that in a moment she wants to have a child that will accomplish spiritually what she was not able to do in the physical world, the material world.

A child as white as the snow is a child both pure and full of faith the color white and steadfast in that faith and purity the snow, winter signaling the time of hardship that won't overcome faith. As the Disney version says, when the queen has dipped the apple into her poison, "The symbol on the skin of what lies beneath!

A child red as blood means she is the expression of perfect love: The queen dies as soon as the child is born because we "cannot serve both mammon and God," i.

Snow White is the "fairest in the land" because she has the greatest virtue that adds to the greatest beauty, or makes even a ugly woman beautiful, if she so practices virtue. Little Snow White, the original Grimm Brothers' tale, can be read here for free ; it's only a couple of pages and quite interesting.

A Tale Of Terror which has some interesting aspects to it, and I will mention it from time to time, but not specifically post on it; it is available for instant viewing on Netflix.

As I mentioned, the original Snow White tale is only a couple of pages, but we are presented with an entire book here. There is an aesthetic response, the idea of us being children again and someone opening our favorite book to read to us, but there is also the validation that the story to be told is published, preserved for all ages and hence of value.

This introduction to the story is also important because in the featurette for Mirror, Mirror, the dwarfs decide to "skip the story book" opening and just get on with the story, which is a reflection of our cynicism today; but Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs knows everything exists within a context, and this intro in writing of what that context is lets us know what that context is.

The blue fabric upon which the book rests symbolizes the "wisdom" being offered up for our consideration in the pages; how do we know that?

The book, like our heroine, is white, so that contained therein is pure and faithful, it can be trusted; it is also edged in gold, symbolizing royalty, and in this case, the "royal wisdom" that will bring us all to happiness if we heed it, like Snow White, or ruin, like the queen, if we don't.

Inwhen Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs was released, who was poor and dressed in rags? The Great Depression was in full-swing, and there was unprecedented unemployment and food lines; like Snow White, most Americans were hoping for that thrill of true love that would get the heartbeat going again and lead the country out of the dark times.

But an economic and historical analysis doesn't explain why the film is so timeless; we might argue it's the great artistry of the illustrations, but with advances in computer animation nearly every day, wouldn't that make Snow White seem old and worthless?

Not that I would ever argue that. It will be a fruitful exercise for us to consider the presentation of the queen's castle pictured here, and compare it to the one we will see in Mirror, Mirror and Snow White and the Huntsman. In this picture, we don't see any decay or ruin: Is that to demonstrate that the queen is a good ruler, and her subjects prosper?

No, it's to show us the "image of health" so when we see the queen, we know she' s not it. This play on opposites is also at work in the two queens this year: The evil queens will look wealthy and beautiful while the subjects poor and miserable. Incorporating strong opposites in films allows an easier comparison--that doesn't even have to be articulated--for the audience to understand how the "balance" of justice will be swayed by the hero and why.

When there is a story that achieves the timeless quality, it's because it's about something that is timeless, and that is the soul. The window of the castle wherein the Evil Queen and Snow White live.Mar 30,  · Walt Disney & the Brothers Grimm: A Comparative Analysis of Snow White Snow White became a part of the Grimm Brothers' fairy tales in and was made into a classic, feature length film by the Walt Disney company in Disney has taken the original ideas of the Brothers Grimm and twisted their plots into ones of a perfect world.

Where everyone can and will be happy together, all is forgiven and forgotten. Brothers Grimm Cinderella Vs. Disney Cinderella. Disney could not have made an exact remake of the fairytale.

Week's Most Popular Posts

The Brothers Grimm telling is not Disney acceptable; more on that later. The Movie, of course has, Cinderella, a wicked stepmother, and wicked stepsisters. Grimm vs. Disney Fairy tales are typically those stories that people read to children that introduce fairies, mermaids, or enchantments of some sort and have the usual “they lived happily ever after, The End” at the completion of the tale/5(1).

Disney vs brothers grims essay

Disney has taken the original ideas of the Brothers Grimm and twisted their plots into ones of a perfect world. Where everyone can and will be happy together, all .

Disney has taken the original ideas of the Brothers Grimm and twisted their plots into ones of a perfect world. Where everyone can and will be happy together, all . Disney vs. Grimm. Buck Holler. Oct 18, Image via Wikipedia. My wife recently wrote an essay for her college English class comparing Disney's film Cinderella to the literary version told by the Grimm brothers. The contrast was revealing. Whether deliberate or incidental, the Disney version seems to effortlessly recast the story within. Essay about Differences Between the Grimm Brother's and Disney's Cinderella - The Glass Slipper Fairytales, the short stories that most children heard as they went to bed, are actually folktales from previous decades.

Essay about Differences Between the Grimm Brother's and Disney's Cinderella - The Glass Slipper Fairytales, the short stories that most children heard as they went to bed, are actually folktales from previous decades.

Disney vs. Grimm | Circe Institute